Is The Opposite of Wonder... Knowing?

Share

The Scenario

A Londoner is on holiday in Australia’s Kakadu National Park with his partner. One night, while his partner reads, he goes outside and lies down. He inhales the scent of eucalyptus and looks up at the vast beauty of the Milky Way stretching from horizon to horizon.

Lying there, he recalls what he was taught about the Milky Way in an old school lesson – the breadth of the galaxy, how many stars it contains, the massive black hole at its centre. He has a flush of satisfaction at his knowledge, pleased that he somehow has the measure of it.

After a minute, he goes back inside to share the amazing facts of the galaxy with his partner. The Milky Way remains overhead, now unseen. Huge, full of mystery… and wonder.

And we don't only do this with galaxies...

The same couple are back in the UK, at breakfast on a Saturday morning. She is watching him butter toast. She doesn’t see him exactly, rather she consults what she knows as she watches him. She can tell you how he takes his coffee, how he’ll vote, what he’ll say about the weather, how he’ll respond to her wish to go for a walk. Her file on him is thick and accurate.

She reaches for it the same way he reached for his file on the Milky Way, and she experiences the same small click – she has the measure of him. She answered the wonder of him years ago, and that knowledge sits where he used to be.

 

The Pattern: Prioritising Knowledge Over Relating

Neither of them is wrong. Their knowledge is accurate. The man did not stop looking at the Milky Way. He simply reduced it to facts, as he replaced his experience of it with his knowledge of it. The woman has not stopped looking at her partner, but she participates less with him as her experience of him is reduced to her answers. Their relationships with the world and each other have become restricted to knowledge.

Of course, we want to be seen and understood by our loved ones. But, being seen does not mean being reduced to a set of facts and answers. We want to be seen so we can be met where we are.

Not all questions need an answer, or have one. But we have come to demand answers for too much. Is there an answer to. music? To love? Or laughter? Of course there are things we can observe about all of these - but answers?

And psychotherapy, or at least the social-media version of it, can contribute to this. It tells you that you are understandable, solvable, fixable. It may tell you that you are traumatised, narcissistically wounded, or avoidantly attached. These may shed light on you. They may help you understand some of your patterns and adjust things. But none of them is the answer to you. You will never be fully explained. And that is not a bad thing.

  

Three Thinkers

‘The world will never starve for want of wonders; but only for want of wonder.’
G.K. Chesterton
‘The most beautiful thing we can experience is the mysterious. It is the source of all true art and science.’
Albert Einstein
‘All real living is meeting.’
Martin Buber

 

Relational Living   a fortnightly letter from Luke West

If something here landed, or missed, reply to this email and tell me.

Looking for therapy? My practice: lukewesttherapy.com